+- American Football Mod (https://www.americanfootballmod.com)
+-- Forum: American Football Mod Forums (/forumdisplay.php?fid=1)
+--- Forum: The Locker Room (/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Thread: Ranking/Analysing Players of CSFL5 (/showthread.php?tid=865)
Ranking/Analysing Players of CSFL5 - kc21 - 9-3-18 8:27 AM
With all of these top 10 lists a lot of the newer people who were starting to come into form in CSFL5 are getting snubbed spots because of our biases towards the older players of the mod. So i’m going to rank everyone who atleast played 1 game or was active at the time during csfl.
Rules of the rankings:
Team Result> Overall Team impact > Skill. So i’ll be weighing how well your team did the most, how much impact you had on your team as an individual, and then pure skill.
People who played 1 game don’t get ranked, not enough sample size for me to rank them.
I’m not ranking yellow because once again he was cheating. I am ranking rawr but you will see the way that handled his draft will HEAVILY impact his placement.
These are MY rankings, if you disagree then we can agree to disagree in advance. This is only MY perspective as the player kc21, we all see the game differently.
THIS IS BASED OFF OF CSFL5 ONLY, MY OVERALL LIST WOULD LOOK A LOT DIFFERENT THAN THIS
With that being said let me get on with this list.
1) Funtastik
- Once again Funtastik had the most well coached team, the most disciplined team, and the way he put together that team top to bottom from the draft was impeccable. Being able to get elite sideline wrs like jeffrey and grogglez early set the ground work for the offense and then he rounded it out by picking the second best rusher in f3(most important position besides qb, remember this for later) and then a very reliable, very solid, very experienced 4th wr in shanks. His draft grade alone is an A or an A+. Then you look at the play, he always covered the best wr on the opposing team, he limited my stats in every game he went against me while also leading his team around him. Well earned MVP and top qb.
2) kc21
- I really thought about putting peyton here because of his impact as qb but thinking about it on offense a lot of the play calls were either to me, or shifting me around to open up the field for my team. The thing that I think puts me ahead of peyton even though hes a qb is the difference in us on defence. LB is the second most impactful position in AFM besides qb and being in my opinion the best rusher of last CSFL it puts my overall worth up to his level if not above.
3) Peyton Manning
- Barely lost out on top qb and barely lost out in the CSFL championship peyton once again showed that with the pieces around him you will probably have to go through him to win a championship. Peytons knowledge as a qb was almost as high as it could get. Near complete understanding of the game. Very similar to IRL peyton. Peyton matched up well ok defense with people who weren’t hyper agile (record,jeff,buttfumble.), but when it came to the people who possess more speed he struggled at times, but always was their for the challenge. He lacked what we like to call “dynamic ability”.
THIS IS WHERE IT GETS INTERESTING
4) Jeffrey
-Jeffrey continued his meteoric rise through the ranks of the pug server into CSFL5. Under the guidance of an elite QB for the first time in his career jeffrey was able to put up numbers that qb’s dream of. He lead the league with 13tds, had the second most catches (while having an 87% of completing his passes), and the 4th most yards. He did this while on the same team as grogglez, so the fact that jeffrey was the number one on that team is a feat in itself. Jeffrey’s next steps would have been to increase his agility and play making ability and assert himself more as a defender.
5) Grogglez
-Grogglez and record are interchangible for what you would want, Grogglez is the superior WR and record is the superior DB. Grogglez put to bed all notions of being “washed” when he got 11 tds, 844 yards (both 2nd) all on 38 caches. He proved once again that when called upon he could answer the call. The true sign of a goat
(Grogglez is 4th in my mind... but thats my bias in my opinion)
6)Tom Brady
- I was going to put JBL here actually but after thinking about it even though JBL finished really strong Tom didn’t have a player of the same magnitude of yellow... Tom was a victim of his draft and the teams he had to go against. Every game tom had to play he either got rushed by: Me, f3, or yellow. Thats a fucking nightmare when record is being covered by peyton, funtastik, and blood. Despite all of this tom put up a good fight and lost a couple close games... and a couple blow outs...
7) JBL
-Im going to get a lot of hate for this but idc, JBLs team was destined for the mext 0-7 team of CSFL after losing blood as a player and losing yellows desire to play and he said “no im not just gonna roll over and get rolled” he beat the express in a close game, beat toms team in a close game to finish the season and then stomped top 6-36.
8) Record
-Record lead the league in yards and was his teams best defender. The things that go against record is his pedestrian completion % of 71%. Record and tom were never able to develope a consistent connection but that still wouldn’t stop record from catching deep balls. Record needed to answer the bell as the top DB he was and limit WRs like me to less yardage than he allowed.
9) F3
- F3 was the best rusher statistically with the most sacks and I only saw a little bit behind me as far as raw skill as a rusher. F3 had the tools to become an elite inside WR but could never get the true feel for the position to use his abilities to the best of his ability. F3s next step was just to get more pug plays to put the puzzle together offensively and to discipline himself in his route running tendencies.
10)Buttfumble
- This is just a case of losing interest in the game at the time... BF was better than his stats and rankings indicate but his IRL distractions were too much for him to care enough at the end (which is fine) but he was still a very solid defender just couldn’t develope chemistry with peyton.
11) Milkman
-Milkman beat out blaze for a starting spot on the express and continued to FEAST off of his relative competition as a “4th” wr. He truly committed to peyton and the express’ system after falling through the draft past teams such as The Outlaws(that one got to him). Milkman showed the fight and desire to improve as a 4th/5th that a qb looks for. No one wants a WR whos happy being mediocre
12)Shanks
-Ole reliable. Shanks wasn’t very impactful as a WR but as a defender he fit the bill to round out funtastiks team in that Goodgoat/Gee role where they might not be featured a lot as a WR but they can still contribute to any defense. Shanks was a victim to time similar to blaze of offense. The mod sped up around him while he stayed the same. I still want to be [eZ] tho
13)Aj
-Tom and AJ continued their connection im this CSFL putting up decent stats for the amount of games he played... Aj had vertical play making ability but as far as consistent route running to sustain long drives there was a lot to be desired. Underrated defender.
14) Blood
-In the time he was with JBL blood showed he was no longer the same WR. Understanding what blood was going through playing for a “lesser” qb I understand the frustration of not the production you would like but knowing bloods talent his stats are unacceptable. 24/40 (60%) was the worst completion percentage for a wr and would be the equivalent of going 6/10 every game. Midway through the season JBL had the chance of getting me and rawr for yellow and Panda. Its possible that would have went on to be a bad trade because regardless jbl went 3-1 in his last games after that. If i completely erased bloods WR stats and took him PURELY as a DB his rating instantly goes up in my head but in this CSFL he showed once again when things start going bad he will not try to diffuse the fires but add to it.
As a talent blood instantly jumps to around the top 5, especially when in the right situation with the right team.
15)Coolbrah
-Not only could he sub in for qb if needed (which it wasn’t) but im pretty sure he can play anywhere on the field, inside or outside on defense, and his rush his nothing to be laughed at... he has a tendency to get insane dives in between the bots to sack the qb.
To be continued...
RE: Ranking/Analysing Players of CSFL5 - Death - 9-3-18 9:35 AM
Min 2 games to be ranked. FeelsBad
RE: Ranking/Analysing Players of CSFL5 - Peyton - 9-6-18 2:44 AM
Pretty solid analysis. Only thing I would say is that Rawr should have been listed. He played 4 games and had 10 tds, on pace to have the most. Yea he benefited from having kc on his side ala kc benefiting from Grogglez back in the day, but he still deserves to be listed. Other than that, I agree with most of it, especially top 5.
RE: Ranking/Analysing Players of CSFL5 - kc21 - 9-6-18 6:07 AM
(9-6-18 2:44 AM)Peyton Wrote: Pretty solid analysis. Only thing I would say is that Rawr should have been listed. He played 4 games and had 10 tds, on pace to have the most. Yea he benefited from having kc on his side ala kc benefiting from Grogglez back in the day, but he still deserves to be listed. Other than that, I agree with most of it, especially top 5.
Rawr was excluded because of how he handled the draft, but I should still list him.
Ill add rawr once I find the motivation to finish.
RE: Ranking/Analysing Players of CSFL5 - jbL - 9-6-18 1:41 PM
Rawr wouldn't have put up the same numbers with Brady and record as his inside wr as he did playing with the Express.
RE: Ranking/Analysing Players of CSFL5 - Funtastik - 9-7-18 4:09 PM
Rawroachi is also a cheater. Must be exempt from any list.
RE: Ranking/Analysing Players of CSFL5 - jbL - 4-5-19 8:49 PM
can we get a csfl 6 ranking Kappa