(4-11-16 12:04 AM)Beaverboys Wrote: (4-10-16 10:21 PM)blood Wrote: (4-10-16 10:02 PM)HamdaN Wrote: this list is a fucking joke lmao
I want an honest to god no troll opinion on which part of this list you have a problem with. Please be specific on the player(s) you have a problem with.
Also if anyone has an issue with this list please explain why you have the issue and what specifically about the list you have an issue with. Since the "inner circle" made this list It would be interesting hearing the opinions of other players. Whether it be where a player is listed or if a player isn't on the list.
First of all, you forgot to put Chosen on the defensive list, and completely forgot Grogglez, veX, and dop (all played 1 game) as well as ParadoX (played 3 games). Intensity didn't play in any games, and Death was never even on a roster.
Jeffrey, Record, Walle, and Eakin are slightly too high offensively. Me, buttfumble, and Chosen are too low offensively. Eakin is ranked above me offensively despite having literally 0 catches for 0 yards in CSFL, and eventually getting cut.
Tom should be listed as a rusher, and should be at least mid-tier. As I said before, you put Rawr, who had 0 sacks all season, over me, when I tied scripter yellow for most sacks and got first-team LB. Defensively, Rawr should be mid-tier, Walle should be mid-low tier, Jeff should be high-tier, and Deadpool should be mid-high tier.
I'm sure I forgot a couple of things but those are the issues I have with it at a glance. I'm not sure if the players are listed in order within the tiers, but if they are I have many more issues with the list.
Chosen was a typo he is mid-low tier I must of missed him on accident.
1. Grogglez, Vex, Dop, and Paradox though playing matches in the csfl did not play enough outside of those specific matches to really get an idea on where they stand with other players.
2. Death plays a decent amount in the pug so he gets on the list.
3. I honestly don't know why I added intensity, someone mentioned him as I was making the list so I added him.
1. Jeffrey in pugs and in the csfl proved to be the best Wide receiver in the mod as of right now. This is also putting kc21 at QB and not at wr. This list isn't 'of all time' but based on the given stats and performance of right now he deserves high tier.
2. I personally believe all the other players you have an issue with are fine in their respective tier but I will say again that this isn't completely based on csfl stats. I'm not manning I don't live and breathe off the stat line. A good example is you and eakin. You weren't picked because of your offensive talent. Comparing you head to head with eakin I can say that eakin is a better wide receiver based on what I have seen between you 2 in the pug server.
- Rawr has proven to be a more effective rusher he also did not rush in the csfl and if he did it was maybe 2 games max.
- Jeff is a good defender but he has even stated him self he isn't a high tier defender.
- Deadpool showed weakness in his defense in the csfl.
There are probably a few players that could be adjusted but only slightly. I have gotten several opinions from multiple players and I agree maybe there can be some minor tweeks to the list but overall I feel as well as others it is a solid list. The list again
was not made from CSFL stats or any specific stat line alone. I actually like to see how a player plays and evaluate the persons performance in different settings and circumstances to determine a more accurate evaluation.
Anything else?
(4-11-16 12:43 AM)Shanks Wrote: Damn Mid-Tier for both offense and defense? Shame.
I actually find that quite impressive considering how much you play
