Home / Announcements / The Final? List - Top 30 Players of All TIme

Thread Closed 
The Final? List - Top 30 Players of All TIme
Author Message
Peyton
Can't pick perfection.
Hall of Fame

Posts: 700
Joined: Feb 2008
CSFL First TeamCSFL First TeamCSFL ChampionTournament MVPCSFL First Team
Quarterback of the YearPlayer of the YearCSFL First TeamCSFL MVPCSFL Champion
Hall of FamerTournament ChampionQuarterback of the YearTournament MVPTournament Champion
Tournament MVPTournament ChampionQuarterback of the YearPlayer of the Year
Post: #1

Criteria to determine the best players of all time:

Quote:Impact on AFM
Greatness during era played relative to greatness of other players and their respective eras.
Stats and productivity in CSFL, PUG and Tournaments - in that weighted order. 50/40/10 split
Longevity
Value to the team
Accomplishments

The greatest of all time - not to be confused with a player's legacy.

#1-5

#1 - Peyton 
CSFL
2x Champion (VI, II), 5 Individual Awards - MVP (II), 3x Top QB (VI, III, II), Top CB (VI)
17 wins - 18 losses (.486) 16 MVPs, 21 Top QBs
393 RTG (1st), 7.7 PPR (2nd)
PUG
24,347 RTG (1st), 7.8 PPR (1st)
TOURNAMENT
3x Champion (Official V, Thanksgiving, Double Elimination II), 8 Individual Awards - 3x MVP (Official V, Thanksgiving, Double Elimination II), 5x Top QB (Official VI, Official V, Thanksgiving, Double Elimination II, Official IV)
352 RTG (1st), 9.4 PPR (4th)

#2 - Funtastik 
CSFL
2x Champion (V, III), 4 Individual Awards - MVP (V), Top QB (V), Top WR (II), Top CB (V)
16 wins - 18 losses (.471) 12 MVPs, 9 Top QBs, 3 Top WRs
377 RTG (2nd), 8.0 PPR (4th)
PUG
15,808 RTG (3rd), 12.0 PPR (Tied 8th)
TOURNAMENT
6x Champion (Official VII, Official VI, Winter Classic, Official IV, Double Elimination I, Official III), 7 Individual Awards - 2x MVP (Official VII, Winter Classic), 2x Top QB (Official VII, Winter Classic), Top WR (Double Elimination I), Top CB (Official V), Top LB (Double Elimination I)
320 RTG (2nd), 10.8 PPR (Tied 5th)

#3 - kc21 
CSFL
1x Champion (IV), 2 Individual Awards - Top WR (V), Top LB (V)
WR: 10 wins - 7 losses (.588) 4 Top WRs
QB: 6 wins - 0 losses (1.000) 5 MVPs, 5 Top QBs
220 RTG (4th), 8.8 PPR (6th)
PUG
23,072 RTG (2nd), 8.3 PPR (2nd)
TOURNAMENT
4x Champion (Official VII, Official VI, Winter Classic, Official V), 4 Individual Awards - MVP (Official VI), 2x Top WR (Official VII, Winter Classic), Top LB (Winter Classic)
191 RTG (5th), 8.3 PPR (2nd)

#4 - Grogglez 
CSFL
3x Champion (VI, V, IV), 2 Individual Awards - Top WR (VI), Top LB (I)
11 wins - 12 losses (.478) 3 MVPs, 8 Top WRs
174 RTG (7th), 11.8 PPR (14th)
PUG
8,652 RTG (9th), 10.8 PPR (5th)
TOURNAMENT
5x Champion (Official V, Thanksgiving, Double Elimination II, Official IV, Summer Showdown), 2 Individual Awards - Top WR (Thanksgiving), Top CB (Thanksgiving)
153 RTG (8th), 12.3 PPR (8th)

#5 - Tom Brady 
CSFL
3 Individual Awards - MVP (IV), Top QB (IV), Top LB (II)
16 wins - 14 losses (.533) 6 MVPs, 16 Top QBs
307 RTG (3rd), 8.3 PPR (5th)
PUG
9,409 RTG (7th), 10.7 PPR (3rd)
TOURNAMENT
1x Champion (Official VI)
93 RTG (13th), 7.8 PPR (1st)

#6-10

#6 - blood 
CSFL
2x Champion (VI, IV), 2 Individual Awards - Top WR (III), Top CB (IV)
14 wins - 10 losses (.583) 2 MVPs, 4 Top WRs
165 RTG (9th), 12.7 PPR (17th)
PUG
7,084 RTG (15th), 14.1 PPR (15th)
TOURNAMENT
4x Champion (Official VII, Official VI, Winter Classic, Official III), 3 Individual Awards - Top WR (Official III), 2x Top CB (Official VI, Double Elimination I)
246 RTG (3rd), 13.9 PPR (12th)

#7 - Arod 
CSFL
1 Individual Award - Top WR (III)
7 wins - 6 losses (.538) 3 MVPs, 1 Top QBs, 5 Top WRs
127 RTG (14th), 9.5 PPR (7th)
PUG
3,608 RTG (25th), 10.8 PPR (4th)
TOURNAMENT
3x Champion (Thanksgiving, Double Elimination II, Official IV), 4 Individual Awards - MVP (Official IV), 2x Top WR (Official VI, Double Elimination II), Top LB (Summer Showdown)
205 RTG (4th), 11.7 PPR (7th)

#8 - yellow 
CSFL
No Accolades
14 wins - 7 losses (.667) 2 MVPs, 9 Top WRs
180 RTG (6th), 9.9 PPR (8th)
PUG
9,624 RTG (6th), 11.0 PPR (6th)
TOURNAMENT
1x Champion (Official VII)
47 RTG (Unranked), 9.8 PPR (Unranked)

#9 - Record 
CSFL
1 Individual Award - Top WR (VI)
7 wins - 16 losses (.304) 2 MVPs, 4 Top WRs
166 RTG (8th), 11.7 PPR (Tied 12th)
PUG
11,556 RTG (5th), 14.6 PPR (18th)
TOURNAMENT
No Accolades
39 RTG (25th), 20.8 PPR (22nd)

#10 - buttfumble 
CSFL
2x Champion (III, II), 1 Individual Award - Top WR (IV)
11 wins - 12 losses (.478) 1 MVPs, 3 Top WRs
150 RTG (10th), 12.9 PPR (18th)
PUG
12,214 RTG (4th), 13.3 PPR (12th)
TOURNAMENT
1x Champion (Official VII)
27 RTG (Unranked), 16.6 PPR (Unranked)

# 11-15

#11 - jeff. 
CSFL
1x Champion (IV)
11 wins - 4 losses (.733) 1 MVPs, 4 Top WRs
113 RTG (19th), 11.1 PPR (10th)
PUG
7,549 RTG (11th), 15.6 PPR (23rd)
TOURNAMENT
No Accolades
68 RTG (19th), 15.7 PPR (17th)

#12 - ParadoX 
CSFL
1 Individual Award - Top WR (I)
8 wins - 6 losses (.571) 2 MVPs, 6 Top WRs
112 RTG (20th), 11.5 PPR (11th)
PUG
2,774 RTG (30th), 15.3 PPR (22nd)
TOURNAMENT
4x Champion (Official VI, Official IV, Double Elimination I, Official III), 3 Individual Awards - 2x Top WR (Official V, Official IV), Top CB (Official III)
150 RTG (9th), 12.8 PPR (9th)

#13 - jeffrey 
CSFL
1x Champion (V), 2 Individual Awards - 2x Top WR (V, IV)
12 wins - 8 losses (.600) 0 MVPs, 4 Top WRs
142 RTG (13th), 12.2 PPR (15th)
PUG
7,017 RTG (16th), 15.2 PPR (21st)
TOURNAMENT
No Accolades
37 RTG (Unranked), 12.0 PPR (Unranked)

#14 - TuPapa 
CSFL
3 Individual Awards - MVP (I), Top QB (I), Top CB (II)
6 wins - 4 losses (.600) 4 MVPs, 5 Top QBs, 0 Top WRs
114 RTG (18th), 7.8 PPR (3rd)
PUG
1,750 RTG (34th), 11.0 PPR (7th)
TOURNAMENT
No Accolades
119 RTG (10th), 10.8 PPR (Tied 5th)

#15 - 'anderson 
CSFL
1x Champion (I)
7 wins - 3 losses (.700) 1 MVPs, 3 Top QBs
73 RTG (25th), 11.7 PPR (Tied 12th)
PUG
N/A RTG, N/A PPR
TOURNAMENT
2x Champion (Double Elimination I, Official III), 4 Individual Awards - 2x MVP (Double Elimination I, Official III), 2x Top QB (Double Elimination I, Official III)
154 RTG (7th), 9.1 PPR (3rd)

# 16-20

#16 - y00na 
CSFL
1x Champion (I), 1 Individual Award - Top WR (I)
10 wins - 6 losses (.625) 2 MVPs, 3 Top WRs
116 RTG (17th), 12.3 PPR (16th)
PUG
2,800 RTG (29th), 13.3 PPR (13th)
TOURNAMENT
1x Champion (Double Elimination I)
88 RTG (Tied 14th), 14.0 PPR (13th)

#17 - jbL 
CSFL
MVP (VI)
7 wins - 9 losses (.438) 7 MVPs, 7 Top QBs, 0 Top WRs
200 RTG (5th), 6.9 PPR (1st)
PUG
4,620 RTG (20th), 16.2 PPR (26th)
TOURNAMENT
No Accolades
21 RTG (Unranked), 13.4 PPR (Unranked)

#18 - dop 
CSFL
2x Champion (VI, IV)
6 wins - 7 losses (.462) 1 MVPs, 1 Top WRs
44 RTG (32nd), 25.5 PPR (32nd)
PUG
1,820 RTG (32nd), 13.9 PPR (14th)
TOURNAMENT
5x Champion (Official V, Thanksgiving, Double Elimination II, Halloween, Official I), 5 Individual Awards - Top WR (Summer Showdown), Top CB (Summer Showdown), 3x Top LB (Official VI, Double Elimination II, Official IV)
182 RTG (6th), 15.6 PPR (15th)

#19 - Rawr 
CSFL
2x Champion (VI, III), 1 Individual Award - Top LB (VI)
8 wins - 7 losses (.533) 0 MVPs, 1 Top WRs
86 RTG (23rd), 15.5 PPR (22nd)
PUG
7,099 RTG (14th), 16.0 PPR (24th)
TOURNAMENT
1x Champion (Official VII)
20 RTG (Unranked), 21.3 PPR (Unranked)

#20 - Deadpool 
CSFL
3x Champion (V, IV, I)
17 wins - 9 losses (.654) 1 MVPs, 1 Top WRs
144 RTG (12th), 15.9 PPR (24th)
PUG
6,858 RTG (17th), 12.8 PPR (11th)
TOURNAMENT
2x Champion (Thanksgiving, Official V), 1 Individual Award - Top CB (Winter Classic)
78 RTG (Tied 16th), 23.3 PPR (23rd)

# 21-25

#21 - Shanks 
CSFL
1x Champion (V)
11 wins - 10 losses (.524) 1 MVPs, 1 Top WRs
119 RTG (16th), 15.2 PPR (21st)
PUG
2,840 RTG (27th), 12.2 PPR (10th)
TOURNAMENT
1x Champion (Halloween)
113 RTG (11th), 13.5 PPR (10th)

#22 - Boo 
CSFL
1x Champion (II), 1 Individual Award - Top WR (II)
11 wins - 11 losses (.500) 1 MVPs, 2 Top WRs
123 RTG (15th), 14.1 PPR (19th)
PUG
4,532 RTG (21st), 16.6 PPR (27th)
TOURNAMENT
4x Champion (Winter Classic, Official V, Thanksgiving, Double Elimination II), 0 Individual Awards
78 RTG (Tied 16th), 19.2 PPR (21st)

#23 - smoked 
CSFL
2 Individual Awards - MVP (III), Top CB (III)
7 wins - 4 losses (.636) 4 MVPs, 4 Top QBs, 0 Top WRs
84 RTG (24th), 11.0 PPR (9th)
PUG
4,649 RTG (19th), 14.6 PPR (19th)
TOURNAMENT
No Accolades
32 RTG (Unranked), 11.0 PPR (Unranked)

#24 - cLarity 
CSFL
No Accolades
3 wins - 1 losses (.750) 2 MVPs, 3 Top QBs
46 RTG (30th), 8.9 PPR (Unranked)
PUG
N/A RTG, N/A PPR
TOURNAMENT
1x Champion (Official IV)
88 RTG (Tied 14th), 15.4 PPR (14th)

#25 - Aj 
CSFL
2x Champion (IV, III)
13 wins - 12 losses (.520) 0 MVPs, 1 Top WRs
148 RTG (11th), 14.3 PPR (20th)
PUG
6,425 RTG (18th), 17.1 PPR (28th)
TOURNAMENT
No Accolades
33 RTG (Tied 27th), 18.9 PPR (19th)

# 26-30

#26 - hyoujin 
CSFL
1x Champion (II)
5 wins - 1 losses (.833) 0 MVPs, 1 Top WRs
44 RTG (31st), 10.7 PPR (Unranked)
PUG
3,634 RTG (24th), 12.0 PPR (Tied 8th)
TOURNAMENT
No Accolades
11 RTG (Unranked), 17.5 PPR (Unranked)

#27 - Blaze 
CSFL
No Accolades
9 wins - 12 losses (.429) 0 MVPs, 2 Top WRs
111 RTG (5th), 16.1 PPR (25th)
PUG
9,273 RTG (8th), 16.1 PPR (25th)
TOURNAMENT
No Accolades
71 RTG (18th), 24.5 PPR (24th)

#28 - craig 
CSFL
1x Champion (III)
3 wins - 0 losses (1.000) 1 MVPs, 1 Top WRs
21 RTG (36th), 12.4 PPR (Unranked)
PUG
2,829 RTG (28th), 14.5 PPR (17th)
TOURNAMENT
1x Champion (Double Elimination II)
48 RTG (21st), 25.2 PPR (25th)

#29 - MilkMan 
CSFL
No Accolades
13 wins - 10 losses (.565) 1 MVPs, 2 Top WRs
104 RTG (22nd), 18.7 PPR (29th)
PUG
8,108 RTG (10th), 18.1 PPR (29th)
TOURNAMENT
No Accolades
12 RTG (Unranked), 37.3 PPR (Unranked)

#30 - Gee 
CSFL
No Accolades
5 wins - 5 losses (.500) 0 MVPs, 0 Top WRs
37 RTG (35th), 24.2 PPR (31st)
PUG
1,812 RTG (33rd), 19.1 PPR (31st)
TOURNAMENT
3x Champion (Winter Classic, Official IV, Official I)
99 RTG (12th), 17.7 PPR (18th)

*PPR = Plays per rating
5-5-20 9:35 PM
Find all posts by this user
Thread Closed 


Messages In This Thread
The Final? List - Top 30 Players of All TIme - Peyton - 5-5-20 9:35 PM