Threaded Mode | Linear Mode

RGriffin3 · 3-6-14 2:40 PM

Someone list these players in top 5 order: Overall.

- Kc
- Manning
- Stevie Johnson
- Grogglez
- buttfumble

buttfumble · 3-6-14 2:50 PM

1. Kc21
2. Grogglez
3. Manning
4. Stevie
5. buttfumble

Tom Brady · 3-6-14 11:20 PM

[center]1. KC or Grogglez
2. KC or Grogglez
3. Stevie or buttfumble
4. Stevie or buttfumble
5. Manning[/center]
The problem is that between KC and Grogglez & Stevie and Buttfumble, you can't go wrong putting one above the other, or one below the other-- its too close to call, because there is no real obvious [red]standout[/red] in those 2 head-to-heads if we're talking about overalls, and the reasoning why Manning is dead last on my list is because playing QB in my books doesn't put you above 1 or 4 other guys who have phenomenal DB (or LB, i.e kc) and WR play, now if we were talking just purely QB overall, that would change.

buttfumble · 3-7-14 8:01 AM

my inconsistency is why I put myself last on this list. The other 4 players have much more experience than me and are just overall more consistent. Hoping to change that though.

Also, I don't know why these are the only names you listed. There are many other players who are better overall than me or Stevie. Funtastik, Arod, Gee, craig, dop, and Shanks (all when active) are just a few I can think of at the moment.

RGriffin3 · 3-7-14 3:44 PM

I am sorry buttfumble, this is my first month playing, and these have been the 5 players that I notice do good in every pug i play in or every pub, I don't know many others that you listed besides Funtastik.