Post Reply 
Tie breaker system CSFL II. Questionable?
Author Message
hyoujin
Retired

Posts: 60
Joined: Jan 2013
CSFL Champion
Post: #15

you guys are arguing nonsensically

we can all agree that if two teams have the same record - the team with the better head to head matchup record moves on to the playoffs or gets the higher seed

IF that record is the same - the second tie breaker won't really matter whether it is based off of point differential or points against - because in the end it would be the point differential or the points against comparison ONLY between those two teams and those two things are correlated

EXAMPLE 1:

Game 1: New Jersey beats Dallas 42-35 (NJ win by 7)
Game 2: Dallas beats New Jersey 42-7 (Dallas wins by 35)

according to Arodӳ suggestion: Dallas moves onto playoffs (35 > 7)
according to Peytonӳ suggestion: Dallas STILL moves onto playoffs because Dallas allowed NJ to score 49 points while NJ allowed Dallas to score 77 points (49 < 77)

notice a similarity? 35 ֠7 = 28 and 77 ֠49 = 28

EXAMPLE 2:

Game 1: New Jersey beats Dallas 70-56 (NJ win by 14)
Game 2: Dallas beats New Jersey 35-28 (Dallas wins by 7)

according to Arodӳ suggestion: NJ moves onto playoffs (14 > 7)
according to Peytonӳ suggestion: NJ STILL moves onto playoffs because NJ allowed Dallas to score 91 points while Dallas allowed NJ to score 98 points (91 < 98)

notice a similarity? 14 ֠7 = 7 and 98 ֠91 = 7

you guys are looking it as an overall against all opponents which it will matter then because of difficulty of the team you face and difference in style

BUT since we are comparing ONLY the matchup tiebreaker between two specific teams you ONLY need to look at the greater margin of win or lesser amount of points allowed between those two specific teams

comprende?
8-8-13 8:58 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Post Reply 


Messages In This Thread
[] - kc21 - 8-7-13, 6:08 PM
[] - Minunat - 8-7-13, 6:11 PM
[] - MilkMan - 8-7-13, 6:13 PM
[] - Doughnot - 8-7-13, 6:14 PM
[] - Gee - 8-7-13, 6:30 PM
[] - Vowel - 8-7-13, 7:13 PM
[] - Peyton - 8-7-13, 7:13 PM
[] - Peyton - 8-7-13, 8:56 PM
[] - Search4theYeti - 8-7-13, 10:29 PM
[] - anderson - 8-8-13, 4:09 AM
[] - Peyton - 8-8-13, 4:24 AM
[] - Arod - 8-8-13, 6:42 AM
[] - craig - 8-8-13, 8:35 AM
[] - hyoujin - 8-8-13 8:58 AM
[] - kc21 - 8-8-13, 9:07 AM
[] - hyoujin - 8-8-13, 9:13 AM
[] - hyoujin - 8-8-13, 9:25 AM
[] - kc21 - 8-8-13, 9:29 AM
[] - smoked - 8-8-13, 9:31 AM
[] - hyoujin - 8-8-13, 9:36 AM
[] - smoked - 8-8-13, 9:44 AM
[] - hyoujin - 8-8-13, 9:50 AM
[] - hyoujin - 8-8-13, 9:55 AM
[] - hyoujin - 8-11-13, 1:38 PM
[] - ronieh - 8-13-13, 3:35 AM
[] - craig - 8-13-13, 6:32 AM
[] - craig - 8-13-13, 6:33 AM
[] - craig - 8-13-13, 6:33 AM
[] - hyoujin - 8-14-13, 11:13 AM
[] - hyoujin - 8-14-13, 11:14 AM
[] - hyoujin - 8-14-13, 11:14 AM
[] - hyoujin - 8-14-13, 11:14 AM
[] - Peyton - 8-25-13, 1:44 AM